Monday, November 14, 2011

American Techniques of War & Iraqi Civilians

President Bush strongly believed that once Saddam Hussein was captured, that the war on terror would be over. Many political leaders thought there were weapons of mass destruction within Iraq, but these allegations would later turn out to be incorrect, and conjured up from false intelligence. Amid the chaos and confusion in Iraq, many of the soldiers within the combat zone were unsure of how to detect an enemy from a civilian. Without rules of engagement and no knowledge of what constituted the enemy, soldiers were told "If it looks like the enemy, shoot it."



Intelligence was minimal at best, and many round-ups by military police officers were based off of hunches. There was no discernment between members of the insurgencies or the common civilians; everyone was simply arrested. Men, women and children were herded out of houses by the American troops, and separated while the men were humiliated in front of their families and neighbors.

American raid on Iraqi house

The Justice Department & the UN Convention Against Torture

The Geneva Conventions were not the only restrictions on how the U.S. could treat prisoners. One of these was the UN Convention against torture, but the U.S. Justice Department found ways to circumvent around this convention. By picking apart the wording, and claiming that there was no precise definition, the Justice Department was able to render this convention powerless.

John Yoo, former Assistant Deputy Attorney General
In August 2002, the Deputy Assistant Attorney General of the Justice Department issued a memorandum to the Alberto Gonzales, the Attorney General of the United States, regarding the Department's views regarding the convention against torture.

Alberto Gonzales, 80th U.S. Attorney General

The Department stated that physical torture must amount to loss of organ function, impairment of bodily function or even death. With the Department's definition of physical pain, it basically allowed extreme and deadly interrogation techniques, with virtually no consequences to the abuser. Although the memo stated that torture was prohibited, the definition was so narrow that it left room for individual interpretation. The letter was the focus of widespread criticism after its' release, with critics agreeing that they were ineffective and left too much room for interpretation. 

The Geneva Conventions & The War on Terror

The Geneva Conventions were a set of rules and standards that regulated and governed the treatment of prisoners of war, and civilians who were detained that were not considered dangerous. This agreement is between the United States and other countries around the world that have agreed upon the terms of the conventions. The most important of the conventions is the third Article, which states that "Protected persons are entitled, in all circumstances, to respect for their persons, their honour, their family rights, their religious convictions and practices, and their manners and customs. They shall, at all times, be humanely treated, and shall be protected, especially against all acts of violence or threats thereof and against insults and public curiosity," (Fourth Geneva Convention). 


The signing of the Geneva Conventions in 1949

The original document from the1864 Geneva Convention


The Geneva Conventions are important to Americans because we try to hold our standards of treatment of prisoners of war higher than other countries. We want our soldiers to be treated humanely if they are captured, therefore, we try to hold this same principle true with prisoners of war we capture. These conventions became an issue during the war on Afghanistan in 2001. The Justice Department determined that they did not apply in the war against al-Qaeda because they did not sign or agree to the conventions, nor do they follow the rules of warfare. Because al-Qaeda targets and kills civilians, they do not deserve to be treated according to the principles of the Geneva Conventions. 


The President's decision to disregard the Geneva Conventions 
in Afghanistan drew outrage from the public

In early 2002, President Bush made the unprecedented decision that the standards of the Geneva Conventions would not hold up for the members of al-Qaeda during the war on terror in Afghanistan. Since the war was dependent upon intelligence gained from prisoners of war, the humane treatment of these detainees was critical and vital to the gathering of intelligence and eventual success of the war. 


The Context of the Abu Ghraib Prison Scandal

In terms of the public view of the Iraq War in the summer of 2003, everything was going great. In May, President George Bush delivered his famous "Mission Accomplished" speech, which boasted that "Major combat operations in Iraq have ended. In the battle of Iraq, the United States and our allies have prevailed," (Ricks 145). This was not the case. No plans had been made for the post-war occupation of Iraq, no weapons of mass destruction had yet been discovered, and there was still much work to do in terms of rebuilding the country. 

President Bush on the USS Abraham Lincoln

Although the White House only acknowledged isolated insurgent attacks in sporadic regions, the insurgency was starting to push full steam ahead. Enemy fighters used roadside car bombs to kill American convoys passing by, and pushed the US military to adapt new techniques to resist and survive the attacks. Due to little intelligence, and military leaders uninformed of an overarching plan, chaos ran rampant the military operations. Meanwhile, American soldiers stationed in Iraq starting losing their momentum and optimistic attitudes towards the war. They were not properly trained to detain and interrogate Iraqi insurgency members, and had no real background on how to depict enemies from civilians. This led to the mass roundup of thousands of Iraqi civilians, and transfer to Abu Ghraib, a small prison outside of Baghdad. 
Abu Ghraib Prison



Political leaders called for interrogation to force intelligence out of prisoners, which would hopefully lead to less bombs, attacks and eventual deaths for the US military. General Sanchez approved harsh interrogation techniques, even harsher than the ones in current operation at Guantanamo Bay, to force intelligence out of the prisoners. "All of the Army's problems in Iraq in 2003-poor planning, clumsy leadership, strategic confusion, counterproductive tactics, undermanning, being overly reactive-came together in the treatment of prisoners," (Ricks 290). In an international scandal that would come to be known as simply "Abu Ghraib," American soldiers and military leaders would be harshly criticized and  punished for the torturous attacks that happened to the human detained at this prison. 
PFC Lynndie England abusing prisoners